Islamic Perspective on Students Wearing a Burqa at Universities in Indonesia: Results from a Survey at Three Universities
Muhammad Hanafiah, Anwar Hafidzi, Wardatun Nadhiroh, Moh. Iqbal Assyauqi, Muhammad Zainal Abidin, Musyarrafah Sulaiman Kurdi, Yokke Andini
Asian Journal for Public Opinion Research. 2019. November, 7(4): 251-260
burqa; Indonesia; university; veiled student; social interactionThe Decree of the Director-General for Islamic Education (DIRJENPENDIS) No. 102 of 2019 states that “the execution of the learning process takes place in the form of interactions between students and lecturers carried out in a humanistic and andragogic manner and dressed decently and with an open face.” The Decree Laws No. 102 of 2019 apply to the rules of Islamic Religious Higher Education Standards to be consistent with Indonesia's National Higher Education Standards as a whole. Previous research states that many factors cause the emergence of radical and splinter movements. The relationship between individuals in the digital and global era today is more formal and professional than family, so that it causes alienation (feeling alienated in the crowd) and triggers some to seek self-mooring ( Koo & Han, 2018 ; Parashar, 2010 ). Several studies have shown that sometimes students wearing the burqa are considered radical. The main factors promoting the use of the veil are the search for identity in religious life and the modeling of Islamic veiled female figures ( Coulson, 2017 ; Mechoulan, 2018 ). The decision to hide (veil/niqab) is a form of religious conversion to further strengthen positive behavior as an extension of religious values that are considered to be moral and signs of good women ( Strabac, Aalberg, Jenssen, & Valenta, 2016 ). This paper claims that the veil is part of a religion. Veiled students often find it difficult in their community to change their lives for the better ( Batum, 2016 ; Braun, 2017 ). The problem is the behavior of other female students who withdraw and sometimes feel that veiled students are "pretentious" because veiled students are considered radical ( Braun, 2017 ; Brown & Saeed, 2015 ; Leibold & Grose, 2016 ). On the other hand, students who use the burqa do not always close themselves off from the surrounding environment ( Hussain, 2019 ; Leyerzapf, Rifi, Abma, & Verdonk, 2016 ). Wearing a burqa can help create a comfortable environment for some women. Self-confidence and positive self-concept become the main things that must be possessed by veiled women in communicating with others ( Łatuszyńska, Wawrzyniak, Wąsikowska, & Furaji, 2013 ). The narration about the wearing of a burqa by students in several universities is that it is indeed part of Islamic Sharia, although there are still those who assume the burqa is a symbol of the Arab ( Jahangir & Manzoor, 2017 ; Zimmerman, 2015). The Islamic view of the burqa as part of Islamic law has always been a controversial issue among Muslims ( Dabbous-Sensenig, 2006 ). The discussion of this research will show that if the community environment already understands the concept of veiling, then the use of the burqa is viewed as positive and has nothing to do with radicalism or terrorism based on understanding the environment. This research focuses more on the role of social background and student engagement in several South Kalimantan universities.
Research MethodsA survey was conducted to learn about the experiences and attitudes of burqa-wearing students in South Kalimantan, Indonesia from May to August 2019. The selection of higher education institutions was based on a previous survey conducted as preliminary research that indicated an increase in the use of the veil/face covering at higher education institutions. The instrument used in this study was a closed questionnaire using a Likert-type scale. The questionnaire items were developed by considering specific indicators: the freedom to wear a burqa on campus, interaction between burqa-wearing students and other female students, the age when the women started wearing a burqa, and the place that inspired or motivated women to wear a burqa. In this study, the population is all burqa-wearing students of three universities in South Kalimantan, Indonesia. Sampled in this study were three general universities, namely, Antasari State Islamic University, Rasyidiyah Khalidiyah Islamic College, and College of Al-Quran Sciences Amuntai, with a total of 100 burqa-wearing respondents who completed a paper-based questionnaire about their experiences and attitudes after being invited by a researcher. A purposive sampling technique was used.
ResultsUniversities in the state of South Kalimantan include Antasari State Islamic University 2 , Rasyidiyah Khalidiyah Islamic College 3 , and College of Al-Quran Sciences Amuntai 4 , with an average sample of 30 people per campus. The number of respondents was 100. The focus of the study were women who were veiled/
DiscussionBased on this research, female students who wear a burqa indicated that wearing a burqa make them feel content. Reconstruction of the environment based on social reality becomes part of the community interaction that is considered normal; they support it. The understanding of the narrative of Islamism with the burqa pattern has a different understanding of life in the campus environment. Most can construct themselves as women who are Muslim, want to be better, maintain their self-desires and those who look can even motivate themselves to provide the best in their environment. As far as social interaction is concerned, the respondents continue to interact with those in the academic community who have different beliefs, although some respondents chose to limit their social interactions to other women who wore hijabs. Closer mosques are an important part of the use of the burqa, because they are filled with teachers from outside the campus. The social interaction of veiled female students did not seem to act as a barrier for those who carry out campus activities and actively communicate with anyone, although from the results of the study there are still some people who think that wearing burqa is strange. This research can be the initial evidence that the students are still able to carry out activities as usual and remain open to communicating with anyone, sometimes even members of the opposite sex. Interaction on campus is also the focus of this research, that students can receive knowledge and are also able to have discussions with their college colleagues. Almost all of them stated that the lecturers provided opportunities and did not prohibit the use of veils in class, although there are sometimes that they still felt awkward in communicating. This research can suggest that the use of the burqa is not part of the map of a radical understanding of Islam, although there are still some who consider it strange. The issues brought up in this study are evidence that religious narratives depend on the place and system. Specifically, for the lecture environment, among those who use the veil, nearly 80% said that the veil was not compulsory and only sunnah to avoid slander and maintain self-respect as a woman. The main evidence is that campus colleagues still accept other colleagues in terms of interacting, communicating, discussing, or other activities. Sometimes when facing lecturers who are also female, they still want to open the face-covering to facilitate interaction.
ConclusionOur survey results demonstrate that it is possible for veiled women to choose to pursue higher education and interact in an academic environment in South Kalimantan, Indonesia. A few limitations of our survey should be mentioned. First, since only university students were interviewed, any veiled young women who may feel limited in their ability to interact socially or educationally were not included in this study. In addition, some veiled students who do not feel freedom to express themselves may have been less likely to participate in this survey, and so their views may be underrepresented. Future research might consider how to reach other veiled women to better understand their attitudes and perceptions about their interactions with society. Also, other parts of burqa-wearing culture on university campuses in Indonesia may be worth considering. For example, future research should examine how certain students who wear burqa are recruited to join burqa-veiled communities, which have been gaining popularity in Indonesia. In addition, surveys should be conducted in other parts of the country to see if our results can be replicated or if attitudes in other locations are different.
Allabadi F. 2008 Controversy: Secular and Islamist women in Palestinian society. European Journal of Women’s Studies 15 (3) 181 - 201 DOI : 10.1177/1350506808091503
Bahramitash R. , Sadegh A. , Sattari N. 2018 Islamist, Islamic and Muslim women. InLow-Income Islamist Women and Social Economy in Iran Springer 35 - 48
Batum D. 2016 Perceptions of work by pious Muslim students: A comparison between the Netherlands and Turkey. Journal of Gender Studies 25 (6) 641 - 654 DOI : 10.1080/09589236.2015.1087307
Braun K. 2017 How much veil is too much veil: On the constitutionality and advisability of face veil bans for German public school students. German Law Journal 18 (6) 1331 - 1358 DOI : 10.1017/S2071832200022367
Brown K. E. , Saeed T. 2015 Radicalization and counter-radicalization at British universities: Muslim encounters and alternatives. Ethnic and Racial Studies 38 (11) 1952 - 1968 DOI : 10.1080/01419870.2014.911343
Coulson N. 2017 A history of Islamic law. Routledge New York, NY
Dabbous-Sensenig D. 2006 To veil or not to veil: Gender and religion on Al-Jazeera’s Islamic law and life. Westminster Papers in Communication and Culture 3 (2) 60 - 65 DOI : 10.16997/wpcc.31
Fournier P. 2013 Headscarf and burqa controversies at the crossroad of politics, society and law. Social Identities 19 (6) 689 - 703 DOI : 10.1080/13504630.2013.842669
Hussain N. 2019 Hijab and social anxiety: Perceptions of university students from Pakistan. Pertanika Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities 27 (2)
Jahangir S. , Manzoor A. 2017 Socio-economic impact and status of the Islamic perspective of veil. Pakistan Journal of Gender Studies 14 161 - 17
Koo G. Y. , Han H. E. 2018 To veil or not to veil: Turkish and Iranian hijab policies and the struggle for recognition. Asian Journal of Women’s Studies 24 (1) 47 - 70 DOI : 10.1080/12259276.2018.1427663
Łatuszyńska M. , Wawrzyniak A. , Wąsikowska B. , Furaji F. 2013 Study on the influence of advertising attractiveness on the purchase decisions of women and men. Journal of International Studies 6 (2) 20 - 32 DOI : 10.14254/2071-8330.2013/6-2/2
Leibold J. , Grose T. 2016 Islamic veiling in Xinjiang: The political and societal struggle to define Uyghur female adornment. The China Journal 76 (1) 78 - 102
Leyerzapf H. , Rifi H. , Abma T. A. , Verdonk P. 2016 Veiled ambitions: Female Muslim medical students and their different experiences in medical education. Unsettling the Self-Other Binary: Cultural Diversity in Dutch Academic Health Care 63
Mechoulan S. 2018 The case against the face-veil: A European perspective. International Journal of Constitutional Law 16 (4) 1267 - 1292 DOI : 10.1093/icon/moy099
Mozaffari M. 2007 What is Islamism? History and definition of a concept. Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions 8 (1) 17 - 33 DOI : 10.1080/14690760601121622
Parashar S. 2010 The Sacred and the sacrilegious: Exploring women’s ‘politics’ and ‘agency’ in radical religious movements in South Asia. Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions 11 (3-4) 435 - 455 DOI : 10.1080/14690764.2010.546117
Strabac Z. , Aalberg T. , Jenssen A. T. , Valenta M. 2016 Wearing the veil: Hijab, Islam and job qualifications as determinants of social attitudes towards immigrant women in Norway. Ethnic and Racial Studies 39 (15) 2665 - 2682 DOI : 10.1080/01419870.2016.1164878